Quick Answer
BIC Xtra Smooth Mechanical Pencils, 40-Count

The BIC Xtra Smooth 40-count is our pick for students: forty 0.7mm pencils with smudge-resistant No. 2 lead and refillable lead and erasers, enough for a backpack, a desk and a locker, where the Pentel Twist Erase III is a 3-pack. Choose the Pentel if you erase a lot or write small: its 0.5mm pencils have built-in twist-up erasers.

See Today’s Price →

Holiday shopping

How we choose: Picks are compared on published manufacturer specifications, current prices, and Amazon customer ratings shown with their review counts. We do not test products ourselves and do not assign our own scores on this page. Learn about our research process | Last updated: November 2026

At a Glance

#ProductAwardPrice
1 Our Top Pick $12.42 as of Nov 21, 3:41 PM CT details
Buy →
2 Best Twist-Up Eraser $16.49 as of Nov 21, 3:42 PM CT details
Buy →
3 Best Rotating-Lead Kit $14.99 as of Nov 21, 3:42 PM CT details
Buy →
4 Best Multicolor Pack $5.59 as of Nov 21, 3:42 PM CT details
Buy →

Related guides we’ve checked

Gift shopping? Holiday Gift Guide 2026: checked picks for everyone on your list.

Mechanical Pencil Sets Buying Guide

Best Mechanical Pencil Sets: Top Picks for StudentsPhoto by Ron Lach / Pexels

A mechanical pencil set has to match how you write: how many pencils you go through, how much you erase, and whether you want a fine 0.5mm line or a sturdier 0.7mm one. The BIC Xtra Smooth 40-count leads this page as the bulk pack for students; the Pentel, uniball and Amazon Basics sets each answer a narrower need.

Lead size: 0.5mm or 0.7mm

0.7mm lead, used by the BIC and Amazon Basics packs, draws a medium line and stands up to heavy-handed writers, which is why it is the usual school size. 0.5mm lead, used by the Pentel Twist Erase III and the uniball Kuru Toga Elite, gives a finer line for math, small handwriting and sketching, but it snaps more easily under pressure. If you break leads often, start with 0.7mm.

Lead grade for school and tests

HB is the same grade as a No. 2 pencil: dark enough to read and scan, firm enough not to smear. BIC sells the Xtra Smooth with smudge-resistant No. 2 lead, Pentel loads the Twist Erase III with Super Hi-Polymer HB lead, and uniball's Kuru Toga Elite uses diamond-infused HB No. 2 lead. Exam rules differ, so check whether a paper test allows mechanical pencils before the day.

BIC Xtra Smooth Mechanical Pencils, 40-Count
BIC Xtra Smooth Mechanical Pencils, 40-Count
See Full Review →

Erasers: top caps or twist-up

Most mechanical pencils have a small eraser under the cap, and it wears out long before the lead. BIC lists refillable erasers for the Xtra Smooth, and the Kuru Toga Elite kit includes five spares. The Pentel Twist Erase III takes a different approach: a long eraser inside the barrel that you twist up as it wears, the better design for anyone who erases constantly.

Bulk packs or one better pencil

A 40-count or 24-count pack stocks backpacks, desks and classroom cups, and it does not matter when one goes missing. A single premium pencil is for someone who writes for hours: the Kuru Toga Elite's rotating lead engine turns the lead as you write, so the tip stays sharp and the line stays even instead of thickening on a worn, flat side.

Why are these mechanical pencils so good?!
▶
Video by JetPens: Why are these mechanical pencils so good?!

Refills and care

Buy lead refills in the same size as the pencil and load them through the top. Keep a few spare erasers, because they are the first part to run out. Retract the lead before a pencil goes into a bag, which protects both the tip and the lining of your backpack.

How we picked: we compared each product's own listing - what it is, what comes in the box, the specifications its maker states and the warranty - and ranked them on how well they answer this page's question. We have not tested these products in hand.

See detailed reviews below ↓

Our Top Pick
BIC Xtra Smooth Mechanical Pencils, 40-Count
$12.42 as of Nov 21, 3:41 PM CT details
at Amazon
Best for: Students and classrooms that need a year's supply of everyday pencils
4.8 from 38,240 Amazon customer reviews

“BIC's Xtra Smooth 40-count: retractable 0.7mm pencils with smudge-resistant No. 2 lead and refillable lead and erasers.”

See Today’s Price →

What we like

  • Forty 0.7mm pencils per pack
  • Smudge-resistant No. 2 lead that erases cleanly, per BIC
  • Refillable lead and erasers
  • Retractable lead: nothing to sharpen

Watch out for

  • Plain bulk-pack pencils: no twist-up eraser or lead-rotating mechanism
Skip if: Artists and small-handwriting writers who want a finer 0.5mm line
See Today’s Price →
Read Full Analysis

Forty pencils is the point of this pack. BIC's Xtra Smooth is a plain, retractable 0.7mm mechanical pencil, and a box of forty is enough to stock a backpack, a desk at home, a locker and a teacher's spare-pencil cup with plenty left over. BIC describes the No. 2 lead as smooth, smudge-resistant and clean to erase, which suits notes, planners and homework, and both the lead and the erasers can be refilled, so a favourite pencil does not have to be thrown out when it runs low. There is nothing to sharpen. What you do not get is a twist-up eraser, a lead-rotating mechanism or a 0.5mm option, which is where the Pentel and uniball pencils on this page come in.

Skip this if: You want a finer 0.5mm line for drawing or small handwriting

Full Specs & Measurements
StyleOriginal Edition
HardnessHB
Ink BaseHybrid
Grip TypeRibbed
Ink ColorBlack
Line Size0.7 millimeters
Body ShapeRound
Drill PointMedium
Closure TypeClick-Off Cap
Item Diameter0.7 Millimeters
Material TypePlastic
Item Dimensions0.98 x 5.63 x 6.02 inches
Hand OrientationAmbidextrous
Included ComponentsEraser
Warranty DescriptionBIC Performance Policy
Water Resistance LevelNot Water Resistant
Writing Instrument FormMechanical Graphite Pencil
Recommended Uses For ProductCalligraphy, Note Taking, Sketching, Writing
Best Twist-Up Eraser
Pentel Twist Erase III Mechanical Pencil, 0.5mm, Black Barrel, Pack of 3
Best for: Students who erase often or write small, and people who sketch
4.8 from 784 Amazon customer reviews

“Pentel's Twist Erase III 3-pack: 0.5mm pencils with Super Hi-Polymer HB lead, a twist-up eraser built into the barrel and a soft, latex-free grip.”

See Today’s Price →

What we like

  • Built-in twist-up eraser for clean corrections
  • 0.5mm Super Hi-Polymer HB lead for a fine line
  • Protective tip design helps stabilize the lead
  • Soft, latex-free grip

Watch out for

  • Only three pencils in the pack
Skip if: Classrooms that need dozens of pencils to share
See Today’s Price →
Read Full Analysis

If you erase a lot, the Twist Erase III fixes the usual problem with mechanical pencils: a tiny top eraser that is gone in a week. Pentel builds a long eraser into the barrel and you twist it up as it wears, so corrections stay clean without smudging the line or tearing the paper. The 0.5mm Super Hi-Polymer HB lead draws a finer line than the 0.7mm pencils on this page, which suits math, small handwriting and sketching, and Pentel's protective tip design is there to steady the lead and cut breakage. Each pencil has a soft, latex-free grip. The catch for a student is quantity: this is a 3-pack, not a classroom supply.

Skip this if: You need dozens of pencils for a class or a family

Full Specs & Measurements
Style0.5
HardnessHB
Grip TypeRibbed
Ink ColorBlack
Line Size0.7mm
Body ShapeRound
Drill Pointall
Closure TypeTwist
Material TypePolymer
Item Dimensions7.36 x 2.76 x 0.59 inches
Hand OrientationAmbidextrous
Included ComponentsEraser
Writing Instrument FormGraphite Pencil
Recommended Uses For ProductDrafting, Drawing, Sketching, Writing
Best Rotating-Lead Kit
uniball™ Kuru Toga Elite Mechanical Pencil Kit, 0.5mm, HB No. 2, Gun Metal
Best for: Note-takers and drafters who want an even line through long sessions
4.7 from 4,716 Amazon customer reviews

“uniball's Kuru Toga Elite kit: one 0.5mm pencil whose rotating lead engine keeps the tip sharp, with a knurled grip, sixty spare leads and five extra erasers.”

See Today’s Price →

What we like

  • Rotating lead engine keeps the tip sharp, per uniball
  • Diamond-infused 0.5mm HB No. 2 lead for dark, fine lines
  • Kit adds sixty 0.5mm leads and five spare erasers
  • Knurled grip and replaceable eraser

Watch out for

  • One pencil per kit: buy a pack if several people need one
Skip if: Students who need a bulk pack to share or lose
See Today’s Price →
Read Full Analysis

The Kuru Toga Elite is the one pencil here built to keep its point. A standard mechanical pencil wears its lead flat on one side, so the line thickens as you write; uniball's rotating lead engine turns the lead as you go so the tip stays sharp, and uniball says that also helps prevent breakage. Its diamond-infused 0.5mm HB No. 2 lead is made for dark, fine lines, the knurled grip gives a firm hold, and the eraser is replaceable. This gun metal kit is a set in itself: one pencil plus sixty 0.5mm leads and five extra erasers. It is a single pencil, though, so it suits a note-taker or drafter rather than a whole class.

Skip this if: You need more than one pencil or tend to lose them

Full Specs & Measurements
Style0.5 mm
HardnessHB
Ink BasePigment
Grip TypeRibbed
Ink ColorGray
Line Size0.5 mm
Body ShapeRound
Drill PointFine
Closure TypeRetractable
Item Diameter2.88 Millimeters
Material TypePlastic
Item Dimensions0.6 x 2.88 x 7.63 inches
Hand OrientationAmbidextrous
Included Components1 Mechanical Pencils
Water Resistance LevelWater Resistant
Writing Instrument FormMechanical Graphite Pencil
Recommended Uses For ProductWriting
Best Multicolor Pack
Amazon Basics Mechanical Pencils 0.7mm
$5.59 as of Nov 21, 3:42 PM CT details
at Amazon
Best for: Families and classrooms that want colour-coded pencils for everyday writing
4.4 from 3,957 Amazon customer reviews

“Amazon Basics' 24-pack of 0.7mm click-advance pencils in multicolour plastic barrels, each with a built-in top eraser.”

See Today’s Price →

What we like

  • Twenty-four 0.7mm pencils in multicolour barrels
  • Click-advance lead from the eraser top
  • Built-in top eraser
  • Amazon Basics says one lasts as long as 2.5 wood-case pencils

Watch out for

  • Plain plastic barrels, and the listing does not state the lead grade
Skip if: Writers who want a cushioned grip or a finer 0.5mm line
See Today’s Price →
Read Full Analysis

Amazon Basics keeps this one simple. Twenty-four 0.7mm mechanical pencils come in multicolour plastic barrels, which makes it easy to tell whose pencil is whose in a shared cup or a family drawer. A click on the eraser top advances a measured amount of lead, the built-in eraser handles everyday corrections, and Amazon Basics says one pencil lasts as long as two and a half wood-case pencils. Each pencil is about six inches long. The listing does not state the lead grade, and there is no twist-up eraser or rotating lead, so treat it as the everyday spare pack rather than a pencil for drawing or long exams.

Skip this if: You need a stated No. 2 lead grade or a cushioned grip

Full Specs & Measurements
StyleSimple
Hardness0.7 mm
Grip TypeNo Grip
Ink ColorBlack
Line Size0.7 Millimeters
Body ShapeRound
Drill PointMedium
Closure TypeRetractable
Material TypePlastic
Item Dimensions6.03 x 0.33 x 0.45 inches
Hand OrientationAmbidextrous
Included ComponentsEraser
Writing Instrument FormGraphite Pencil
Recommended Uses For ProductWriting

Frequently Asked Questions

What mechanical pencil lead size should I use?
0.7mm is the everyday size for schoolwork and notes, and it breaks less under pressure; the BIC and Amazon Basics packs here are 0.7mm. 0.5mm gives a finer line for small handwriting, math and sketching; the Pentel Twist Erase III and the Kuru Toga Elite are 0.5mm.
Can I use a mechanical pencil on a standardized test?
Check that test's own rules first, because they differ, and some paper exams ask for wooden No. 2 pencils only. Where mechanical pencils are allowed, use No. 2 (HB) lead: BIC, Pentel and uniball list No. 2 or HB lead for the pencils on this page.
What does a rotating lead mechanism do?
In the uniball Kuru Toga Elite, a rotating lead engine turns the lead as you write, so the tip stays sharp instead of wearing flat on one side and the line stays even. uniball says it also helps prevent breakage.
Can you refill mechanical pencils?
Yes. You load new lead of the same size through the top. BIC lists refillable lead and erasers for the Xtra Smooth, Pentel's Twist Erase III takes refill lead, and the Kuru Toga Elite kit comes with sixty 0.5mm leads and five spare erasers.
Are mechanical pencils better than wooden pencils?
For a steady line, yes: there is nothing to sharpen and the point stays the same size. Amazon Basics says one of its mechanical pencils lasts as long as two and a half wood-case pencils. Wooden pencils still suit very young children and heavy-handed writers who snap thin leads.

How We Chose These Products

Ranked from each set's own listing: lead size and grade, the eraser (top cap or twist-up), how many pencils and refills come in the pack, and features such as a rotating lead engine.

We compare each product’s Amazon listing, the manufacturer’s published specifications and Amazon customer ratings, shown with their review counts as Amazon’s data, and rank the products on how well they answer this page’s question. We do not test products in hand and we do not run our own analysis of review text. A publication or expert is named only where we cite its published findings about that product. No manufacturer paid for placement on this page.

A price appears only when Amazon’s API supplied it at a recent daily refresh, with the date and time beside it, and is withdrawn at 4 AM Central on the day after it turns 24 hours old; otherwise use “Check price on Amazon” for the live price. Read our full methodology →

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. When you buy through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep the reviews free and the data updated. Our recommendations are based on data, not who pays us. Learn more →
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. Prices appear on this site only when Amazon’s API supplied them at a recent daily refresh, with the date and time beside them; each is withdrawn at 4 AM Central on the day after it turns 24 hours old. Certain content that appears on this site comes from Amazon. This content is provided “as is” and is subject to change or removal at any time.