Best American Girl Dolls 2026: Truly Me, WellieWishers & My First Dolls
American Girl's Truly Me #107 is our pick: an 18-inch doll with brown eyes and straight brown hair who arrives fully dressed in an AG Star Squad outfit with an extra shirt, for ages 6 and up. Choose WellieWishers Camille if your child is 4 or 5 and needs a smaller 14.5-inch doll.
See Today’s Price →
“An 18-inch Truly Me doll with brown eyes, layered straight brown hair and light-to-medium skin, dressed in an AG Star Squad outfit with pink sneakers and an extra shirt.”
See Today’s Price →What we like
- 18-inch Truly Me doll with brown eyes and layered straight brown hair
- Arrives in an AG Star Squad jacket, star-print tee, faux-denim skirt, striped knee socks and pink sneakers
- An extra pink striped shirt for dress-up
Watch out for
- Its listing gives no detail on the doll's body or hair care
Read Full Analysis
Truly Me #107 is the classic 18-inch American Girl doll. She has brown eyes, layered straight brown hair and light-to-medium skin with warm undertones, and she arrives ready to play in an AG Star Squad jacket with white faux-leather sleeves, striped trim, an embroidered AG logo on the chest and a large star patch on the back. Under it are a white tee with a multicolored star print, pink underwear, a faux-denim skirt, white knee-high socks with colourful stripes and pink sneakers, and a second pink striped shirt is included for dress-up. American Girl lists her for ages 6 and up. Her listing does not describe her body, so check those details on Amazon if they matter to you.
Skip this if: Your child is under 6 - a smaller or softer American Girl doll suits younger children
“A 14.5-inch WellieWishers doll with blue eyes, a freckle and silky blond hair to brush, dressed in a mermaid leotard, foil-dot skirt, shell headband and blue wellie boots.”
See Today’s Price →What we like
- 14.5-inch doll sized for younger children
- Silky blond hair that can be brushed and styled
- Mermaid outfit: foil-print leotard, foil-dot skirt and a shell headband
- Blue wellie boots with red fins
Watch out for
- At 14.5 inches she takes different-size clothes from American Girl's 18-inch dolls
Read Full Analysis
WellieWishers is American Girl's smaller line, and Camille is 14.5 inches tall, which American Girl calls sized just right for younger girls. She has blue eyes, a freckle on one cheek and silky blond hair that can be brushed and styled. Her outfit is a mermaid look: a shiny blue leotard with a mermaid-scale foil print, a sea-blue foil-dot skirt over a coral mesh underskirt with a glitter waistband, a headband with two shells, light-pink underwear and blue wellie boots with red fins and smiley fish faces. Her listing is for ages 4 and up. Clothes for American Girl's 18-inch dolls are a different size.
Skip this if: You want a doll that shares clothes with an 18-inch doll
“A 13.5-inch knit plush Samantha doll with an embroidered face and a sewn-on outfit inspired by her signature look, with a Hello, Samantha board book, for ages 18 months and up.”
See Today’s Price →What we like
- 13.5-inch knit plush doll with an embroidered face
- Sewn-on outfit inspired by Samantha's signature look
- Comes with the Hello, Samantha board book
- Made for ages 18 months and up
Watch out for
- The outfit is sewn on, so there is no dressing and undressing
Read Full Analysis
My First Samantha introduces one of American Girl's historical characters to toddlers. She is a 13.5-inch knit plush doll with brown yarn hair in a large gingham bow and a ponytail braid, rosy-pink cheeks and an embroidered face. Her outfit is sewn on and inspired by Samantha's signature look: a multicolored checked dress with a pleated front, a red ribbon belt with an embroidered golden buckle, white bloomers, black tights and black faux-leather Mary Jane shoes. She comes with a Hello, Samantha board book written for younger children and illustrated by Sydney Hanson. American Girl lists the set for ages 18 months and up.
Skip this if: Your child wants a doll with clothes to change and hair to style
Frequently Asked Questions
What age is an American Girl doll for?
What does Truly Me mean in American Girl?
Do WellieWishers clothes fit Truly Me dolls?
What comes with My First Samantha?
What does Truly Me #107 come with?
How We Chose These Products
Ranked from each American Girl listing on the age it is made for, its size and what comes in the box. We do not test toys in hand.
We compare each product’s Amazon listing, the manufacturer’s published specifications and Amazon customer ratings, shown with their review counts as Amazon’s data, and rank the products on how well they answer this page’s question. We do not test products in hand and we do not run our own analysis of review text. A publication or expert is named only where we cite its published findings about that product. No manufacturer paid for placement on this page.
A price appears only when Amazon’s API supplied it at a recent daily refresh, with the date and time beside it, and is withdrawn at 4 AM Central on the day after it turns 24 hours old; otherwise use “Check price on Amazon” for the live price. Read our full methodology →

