Best Fly Fishing Reels (2026)
The Redington Behemoth delivers a large-arbor carbon drag system at half the price of Ross or Lamson alternatives — a genuine value gap for 5/6-weight trout and bass applications. Best for intermediate anglers who want proven performance without the premium.
See Today’s Price →At a Glance
| # | Product | Award | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Redington Behemoth Fly ReelRedington |
Best Overall | Check price on Amazon Buy → |
| 2 | Redington Crosswater IVRedington |
Budget Pick | $129.99 as of Nov 21, 8:50 AM CT details Buy → |
| 3 | Redington Crosswater IV Fly Reel,…Redington |
Best Budget | $79.99 as of Nov 21, 8:50 AM CT details Buy → |
“Redington Behemoth 5/6 Fly Reel uses carbon disc drag that delivers smooth, consistent stopping power for fighting larger trout and bass — the best large arbor reel under $100.”
See Today’s Price →What we like
- Large arbor
- Carbon drag
- 5/6 weight
- Redington quality
Watch out for
- Large arbor design adds weight compared to traditional click-pawl reels
- Carbon fiber drag system requires break-in period to smooth out
- Matte finish shows scratches from rocky stream access
Read Full Analysis
The Redington Behemoth 5/6 is named accurately — it's built for the harder fights that come with larger fly fishing applications. The carbon disc drag system is the defining feature: carbon fiber drag washers deliver smooth, consistent resistance without the startup inertia that ruins light tippet when a fish takes off unexpectedly. Large arbor geometry means the line wraps in bigger loops, which reduces line memory and coils on the water while also picking up line faster during a fish fight. It's the premium pick in this lineup. The 5/6 weight designation covers the most versatile range in trout and small streamer fishing — light enough for dry fly presentations, heavy enough to handle indicator rigs and streamers with split shot. Carbon drag systems are typically found at higher price points; Redington's approach of putting serious drag hardware in a mid-priced reel is what earns the Behemoth its reputation among value-focused fly anglers. The main consideration is that large arbor reels are physically larger in diameter than standard arbor reels — they don't fit in every reel seat on older rods. Check your rod's reel seat diameter before buying.
“Redington Crosswater IV Prespooled with 5WT line lets you rig up and fish the same day — the all-in-one option for fly fishers who want to skip the line selection process.”
See Today’s Price →What we like
- Pre-spooled 5WT line
- 4/5/6
- Budget
- Ready to fish
Watch out for
- Pre-spooled line is basic quality — experienced anglers often re-spool immediately
- Die-cast weight limits feel of a balanced rod-reel combo
- Included line is adequate for stocked trout but not demanding presentations
Read Full Analysis
The Redington Crosswater IV Prespooled with 5WT line removes the most frustrating barrier to entry in fly fishing: getting a reel properly spooled with backing, fly line, and leader before you can fish. This version comes ready to fish out of the box with 5-weight fly line already installed. It's the same price as the bare Crosswater IV, making the prespooled version the obvious choice for beginners or anyone buying a setup for a specific application where they just want to fish, not gear-configure. The die-cast aluminum construction handles normal freshwater use reliably, and Redington's quality control ensures the reel functions smoothly at this price point. The drag system is click-and-pawl rather than disc drag — adequate for trout fishing but less smooth under the sustained pressure of a large fish. For smaller trout streams and typical fly fishing applications, click-and-pawl drag is entirely functional. The prespooled convenience is the main decision point: if you already have backing and fly line or want to choose your own line weight and taper, the bare Crosswater IV saves the same $0 (identical price). If you want to be fishing same-day, the prespooled version is the right choice.
“Redington Crosswater IV die-cast reel is the most affordable way to get a reliable large arbor reel — durable drag system and fast line retrieval for freshwater fishing.”
See Today’s Price →What we like
- 4/5/6 weight
- Die-cast
- Durable
- Budget Redington value
Watch out for
- Die-cast construction is heavier than machined aluminum alternatives
- Drag system is adequate for trout but not suited for heavy salmon or steelhead
- Crosswater finish shows reel seat marks after repeated use
Read Full Analysis
The Redington Crosswater IV in its bare configuration is the most affordable way into a reliable fly reel. Die-cast construction at this price point is standard across entry-level fly reels, and Redington's version is consistently reviewed as one of the better executions of that construction — the tolerances are tight enough that the reel doesn't wobble or develop play over time the way cheaper die-cast options do. The 4/5/6 weight range makes it adaptable across trout applications from small streams to larger rivers, and the reel changes direction (left or right hand retrieve) with a simple conversion. Click-and-pawl drag is functional for typical trout fishing; it won't win a tug-of-war with a running salmon but handles a 16-inch brown trout cleanly. At the same price as the prespooled version, this is the right buy for anglers who already have fly line or who want to choose their own taper and line brand. If you're outfitting a guest, student, or secondary setup where convenience matters more than customization, see the prespooled version above. Both deliver the same reel at the same entry price point.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does fly reel quality matter for trout fishing?
What size reel do I need for trout?
Should I buy a reel with a backing already installed?
What size fly fishing reel do I need to match my rod weight?
Do I need a large arbor fly reel, and what is the advantage?
How We Chose These Products
We compared 5 fly fishing reels on drag smoothness, arbor design, weight, machining quality, line capacity, and price-to-performance ratio. Products were selected for verified Amazon availability and proven reputations across freshwater applications.
We compare each product’s Amazon listing, the manufacturer’s published specifications and Amazon customer ratings, shown with their review counts as Amazon’s data, and rank the products on how well they answer this page’s question. We do not test products in hand and we do not run our own analysis of review text. A publication or expert is named only where we cite its published findings about that product. No manufacturer paid for placement on this page.
A price appears only when Amazon’s API supplied it at a recent daily refresh, with the date and time beside it, and is withdrawn at 4 AM Central on the day after it turns 24 hours old; otherwise use “Check price on Amazon” for the live price. Read our full methodology →
